Used Gun Stores in New York

21 of the 311 gun stores we track in New York have used guns. A map listing shows a store's category and hours, not whether its shelves include trade-ins and consignment pieces alongside new stock — that detail either shows up buried in a random review or not at all. Every store here has used guns confirmed from its own website or current inventory listing, not inferred from one customer mentioning a used rack. Full listings for every city are on the New York page.

Whitehall 2

DOC's Sales and Service Used & consignment

12140 RT-22, Whitehall, NY 12887-4606

🕒 Friday 9am - 4pm

+15183072077 Website All Whitehall gun stores

Doc's Sales And Service Used & consignment

12140 State Route 22, Whitehall, NY 12887-4606

🕒 Friday 9am - 4pm

+15184995394 Website All Whitehall gun stores

Auburn 1

S&S Sales GunsmithingUsed & consignment

6618 Canoga Rd, Auburn, NY 13021

3157307512 Website All Auburn gun stores

Bloomfield 1

Turnbull Restoration GunsmithingUsed & consignment

6680 State Route 5 and 20, Bloomfield, NY 14469-9208

+15856576338 Website All Bloomfield gun stores

Buffalo 1

Blue Tuna FFL transfersGunsmithingUsed & consignment

870 Ontario St, Buffalo, NY 14217-2252

🕒 Thursday: 10:00am

+17168741150 Website All Buffalo gun stores

Canajoharie 1

McCARTHY GUNS LLC. Used & consignment

217 Erie Blvd, Canajoharie, NY 13317

🕒 Tuesday 4:30pm

+15186734867 Website

Canastota 1

Frank's Shooting Supply FFL transfersGunsmithingUsed & consignmentReloading supplies

7392 Oxbow Rd, Canastota, NY 13032

+13156973365 Website

Carmel Hamlet 1

Precision Armory FFL transfersUsed & consignmentClasses & CCW

421 NY-52, Carmel Hamlet, NY 10512

🕒 Thursday 10am-5pm

+18452251130 Website

Interlaken 1

Interlaken Guns & Ammo FFL transfersGunsmithingUsed & consignmentReloading supplies

8268 N Main St, Interlaken, NY 14847

🕒 Monday – 2pm

+16075324867 Website

Lee Center 1

Giacomo Sporting USA GunsmithingUsed & consignment

6234 Stokes Lee Center Rd, Lee Center, NY 13363-2738

+13153361356 Website All Lee Center gun stores

Lowville 1

NO.4 Tactical Used & consignmentClasses & CCW

7646 Number Four Road, Lowville, NY 13367

3152600100 Website All Lowville gun stores

Marcy 1

Frank's Guns Used & consignment

9103 River Rd, Marcy, NY 13403

3157360062 Website

Mineola 1

Equilibrium Firearms FFL transfersGunsmithingUsed & consignmentClasses & CCW

283 Willis Ave, Mineola, NY 11501-1522

15167888999 Website All Mineola gun stores

New Hyde Park 1

Millennium Firearms FFL transfersUsed & consignment

1847 Highland Ave, New Hyde Park, NY 11040-4049

+15165003000 Website All New Hyde Park gun stores

Oakdale 1

Dark Storm Industries FFL transfersGunsmithingUsed & consignmentNFA / Class 3Classes & CCW

4116 Sunrise Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769-1013

+16319673170 Website

Oakfield 1

Tinker Tactical FFL transfersUsed & consignment

2839 Lockport Rd, Oakfield, NY 14125-9753

+15854516829 Website

Perinton 1

Penfield Armory FFL transfersGunsmithingUsed & consignmentReloading supplies

191 Whitney Rd, Perinton, NY 14526-2318

+15853842800 Website

Port Ewen 1

M1 Firearms & Cerakote FFL transfersGunsmithingUsed & consignmentClasses & CCW

By appointment , Port Ewen, NY 12401

+18455147474 Website

Round Lake 1

Zack's Sports FFL transfersGunsmithingUsed & consignmentClasses & CCW

2138 US-9, Round Lake, NY 12151

🕒 Friday 10AM - 6PM

+15188992799 Website

Saugerties 1

Saugerties Outfitters FFL transfersUsed & consignmentReloading supplies

470 Old Route 32, Saugerties, NY 12477-4225

18452479660 Website

Wallkill 1

Wallkill River Small Arms FFL transfersGunsmithingUsed & consignmentClasses & CCWReloading supplies

2332 RT-300, Wallkill, NY 12589-3952

🕒 Fri 11am

+18443084867 Website

Bring a valid photo ID and expect the same background check as buying new. Inspect a used gun's bore, action, and finish in person before buying, and ask the shop to let you field-strip and function-check it, since return policies on used firearms are often more limited than on new ones.